Keep vs Replace

Repairs on the car you have, or payments on a new one? Both paths counted in full over the same three years.

Should you keep fixing the car you have or replace it? Compare 3 years of repairs, reliability risk, and insurance against a replacement's payment, depreciation, and insurance, and see the month the cheaper path flips. The sample is filled in so you can see a result right away.

Keep: your current car
Replace: the next car
Learn more about keeping or replacing a car

Keep fixing your car or replace it?

The common rule that you should replace a car once repairs exceed a car payment leaves out half the picture. A new car's payment is only part of its cost; it also loses value quickly, and insurance on a newer, more valuable car can cost more. An older car's repairs are lumpy and uncertain, but a car you own outright loses value slowly. A fair comparison counts both cars the same way: money paid out plus the value each one loses over the same period.

The Keep vs Replace tool runs that comparison month by month for three years. Your car's expected repairs come from your own estimate or from Consumer Reports' maintenance and repair costs for the cheapest, median, or costliest of 29 brands at your car's age. It shows the 3-year totals, the crossover month where the cheaper path changes, and how the answer moves if the repair estimate is half or 50% more than you expect. Safety problems such as failing brakes, steering, or frame rust are reasons to act regardless of the math.

Frequently asked questions

When does replacing an old car beat paying for repairs?

Compare the full cost of each path over the same period, not repairs against a car payment. A replacement loses value fast, about 20% in its first year according to Carfax and Kelley Blue Book, and over three years that loss can outweigh several thousand dollars of repairs. Replacing tends to win when large repairs keep recurring or the car is no longer safe.

Where do the prices, rates and tax rules come from?

Each default is stamped with its source and as-of date under "How this is calculated" in the tool that uses it. Where no single authoritative number exists, the tool shows a typical reported range instead of inventing one.

Does AutoSmith send my VIN or my numbers anywhere?

No. Every calculation runs in your browser and the site makes no analytics or tracking calls. This browser remembers only your theme.

How AutoSmith works

What is new