When is GAP insurance worth buying?
GAP, short for guaranteed asset protection, pays the difference between what you still owe on a car loan and what your insurer pays for the car after a total loss or theft. Collision and comprehensive coverage pay the car's actual cash value, not your loan balance, so in the months when you owe more than the car is worth, that shortfall is yours. Most GAP products do not cover your deductible. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau notes that GAP is optional, that you can decline it at the dealer, that your own insurer or lender may sell it, and that you may be owed a refund if you sell, refinance, or pay off the loan early.
Whether GAP can ever pay depends on two curves: the loan balance falling with each payment and the car's value falling with depreciation. Carfax and Kelley Blue Book both put first-year depreciation at about 20%, with roughly 55% to 60% gone after five years. A small down payment, taxes and fees rolled into the loan, a long term, or negative equity from a trade-in all push the balance above the value. The GAP Insurance tool draws both curves month by month, shades the months you are underwater, and compares the dealer's one-time price with insurer GAP for just those months.
Frequently asked questions
Is GAP insurance worth it?
GAP pays the difference between what you owe on the loan and your insurer's actual-cash-value payout after a total loss, and usually not your deductible. It can pay only in months when the loan balance is higher than the car's value, so with a solid down payment you may never need it. When you do, GAP added to your auto policy is usually far cheaper than the dealer's one-time price: typical reported ranges are $50 to $250 a year versus $400 to $1,000 (as of November 2026).
Where do the prices, rates and tax rules come from?
Each default is stamped with its source and as-of date under "How this is calculated" in the tool that uses it. Where no single authoritative number exists, the tool shows a typical reported range instead of inventing one.
Is AutoSmith financial, tax or legal advice?
No. AutoSmith is education: arithmetic on the numbers you enter, with every formula shown. Your loan contract, your insurer, your tax preparer and your state motor-vehicle agency are the binding sources.