Winter Tires

All-season, all-weather and winter tires compared by cost per season, and when a second set of wheels pays for itself.

Winter tires look expensive at the counter, but while they are on the car your other tires are not wearing out. Compare all-season, all-weather, and winter tires by cost per season, including the wear offset, mounting versus a second set of wheels, and a recommendation for your climate. The sample is filled in so you can see a result right away.

Your winters and driving
Set of four tires, before installation ($)
How long each set lasts
Installation and a second set of wheels ($)
Learn more about winter tires

Winter tires, all-weather, or all-season: what does each cost per season?

The sticker price of a winter set is the wrong number to compare. While winter tires are on the car, your all-season tires are not wearing out, so they last more seasons, and the real extra cost of running two sets is the winter set spread over its life minus the all-season tread you save, plus the cost of swapping. Tires also age out: many automakers say to replace tires six years after production regardless of tread, which caps how long a lightly used set can last. All-weather tires carry the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol and stay on all year, a one-set middle ground for mixed climates.

Swapping costs decide the second half of the math. Remounting the same wheels means a mount-and-balance job twice a year, while a second set of wheels turns each change into a cheaper wheel swap after a one-time purchase of wheels and tire-pressure sensors. The Winter Tires tool prices all four setups per season, shows how many seasons the second wheel set takes to pay for itself, and recommends a setup for your climate band. University of Michigan research found winter tires stop about 35% shorter than all-seasons on packed snow, and that a two-wheel-drive car on winter tires out-brakes a four-wheel-drive car on all-seasons.

Frequently asked questions

Are winter tires worth the cost?

Where roads stay below 45 degrees F for weeks, usually yes. Winter tires stop about 35% shorter than all-seasons on packed snow (University of Michigan), and while they are on the car your other tires are not wearing out, so the real extra cost per season is far below the sticker price. Mounting each swap or buying a second set of wheels decides the rest.

Where do the prices, rates and tax rules come from?

Each default is stamped with its source and as-of date under "How this is calculated" in the tool that uses it. Where no single authoritative number exists, the tool shows a typical reported range instead of inventing one.

Does AutoSmith send my VIN or my numbers anywhere?

No. Every calculation runs in your browser and the site makes no analytics or tracking calls. This browser remembers only your theme.

How AutoSmith works

What is new