Trade in or sell privately? Count the sales-tax credit
A private buyer usually pays more than a dealer's trade-in offer, but the headline difference is not your real gain. In most states the trade-in value is subtracted from the taxable price of your next car, so trading in also saves sales tax on the trade amount. The rules differ: California, Hawaii, Virginia, and Washington, DC give no credit; Michigan caps the credit at $12,000 for 2026; Ohio allows it only on new-vehicle purchases; Oklahoma applies it to only part of its tax; and South Carolina caps its whole fee at $500. Selling privately also costs money and time for detailing, listings, inspections, and meeting buyers.
The Trade-In vs Private Sale tool applies a stamped 50-state plus DC table of trade-in rules and state-level rates, each linked to a state revenue, motor-vehicle, or statute page. Enter your combined local rate, your offer, and a realistic private price, and the tool shows the net of each path, the private price you would need to break even, and safe-selling basics.
Frequently asked questions
Do I save sales tax by trading in my car?
In most states the trade-in value is subtracted from the taxable price of the next car, so a $15,000 trade at a 6% rate saves $900. California, Hawaii, Virginia, and Washington, DC give no credit; Michigan caps it at $12,000 in 2026; Ohio gives it only on new-car purchases; and states without a sales tax on vehicles have nothing to credit.
Where do the prices, rates and tax rules come from?
Each default is stamped with its source and as-of date under "How this is calculated" in the tool that uses it. Where no single authoritative number exists, the tool shows a typical reported range instead of inventing one.
Is AutoSmith financial, tax or legal advice?
No. AutoSmith is education: arithmetic on the numbers you enter, with every formula shown. Your loan contract, your insurer, your tax preparer and your state motor-vehicle agency are the binding sources.