Lemon Law

Your repair history against your state's lemon-law presumption, the steps from the dealer to court, and a notice letter to the manufacturer.

A new car that keeps going back for the same defect may be a lemon under your state's law. Enter your repair history to see where you stand against your state's presumption (the repair count or days out of service that make the case), the dispute ladder from dealer to court, the documents to gather, and a notice letter to the manufacturer. The sample is filled in so you can see a result right away; nothing you type is saved or sent.

The car
The defect and the repairs
For the notice letter (optional, never saved)

State rules last checked for the ten states covered. Every state row is re-checked each November against its source.

Learn more about lemon laws

Is my new car a lemon?

State lemon laws for new vehicles mostly work by presumption: if the same defect survives a set number of repair attempts, or the car spends a set number of days in the shop, within a set period after delivery, the law presumes it is a lemon and the manufacturer owes a refund or a replacement. The numbers vary. Florida, Pennsylvania, Ohio and Georgia presume a lemon after three repairs of the same defect, while California, Texas, New York, Illinois, North Carolina and Michigan use four. Only some set a lower count for a defect that could cause death or serious injury: two in California and Texas, one in Ohio and Georgia.

The route varies too: written notice to the manufacturer and a final repair attempt (part of the presumption in Texas, Florida, Georgia, North Carolina and Michigan), then a dispute program (the manufacturer's, such as BBB AUTO LINE, or a state-run program in Florida, Georgia, New York and Texas), then court. Under the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, any written warranty, new or used, can be enforced in court, with attorney fees for a consumer who wins. The Lemon Law tool compares your repair history with your state's presumption and drafts the notice letter.

Frequently asked questions

How many repair attempts make a car a lemon?

It depends on the state: three repairs of the same defect in Florida, Pennsylvania, Ohio and Georgia, four in California, Texas, New York, Illinois, North Carolina and Michigan, and fewer for a serious safety defect in some states. Each state also counts days out of service, usually 30, and limits the period after delivery.

What comes before court in a lemon-law case?

Usually written notice to the manufacturer and a final repair attempt (part of the presumption in Texas, Florida, Georgia, North Carolina and Michigan), then a dispute program, either the manufacturer's, such as BBB AUTO LINE, or a state-run program in Florida, Georgia, New York and Texas, and then court.

What does federal warranty law add?

Under the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, any written warranty, new or used, can be enforced in court, with attorney fees for a consumer who wins.

Is AutoSmith financial, tax or legal advice?

No. AutoSmith is education: arithmetic on the numbers you enter, with every formula shown. Your loan contract, your insurer, your tax preparer and your state motor-vehicle agency are the binding sources.

How AutoSmith works

What is new