Diminished Value

A crash on the history report lowers what the car sells for, even after a good repair. What that loss may be, and how to claim it.

A repaired car with an accident on its record usually sells for less than the same car without one. That gap is diminished value, and when another driver caused the crash you can often claim it from their insurer. Enter the car and the repair to get a value-loss band with the method shown, what the insurers' "17c" formula would offer and why it runs low, your state's rule, and a claim-letter draft. The sample is filled in so you can see a result right away; nothing you type is saved or sent.

The crash
The car and the repair
For the claim letter (optional, never saved)

State rules last checked for the ten states covered. Every state row is re-checked each November against its source.

Learn more about diminished value

Diminished value and the 17c formula

A car with a crash on its history report usually sells for less than the same car without one, even after a good repair. That difference is diminished value. When another driver caused the crash, many states let you claim it from their insurer along with the repair; claiming it from your own insurer is rare, and Georgia is the clear exception after the 2001 State Farm v. Mabry decision.

Many insurers start with the "17c" formula, which came out of the Georgia class-action settlement that followed Mabry: 10% of the car's value, times a damage modifier from 0 to 1, times a mileage modifier that falls to 0 at 100,000 miles. A 2023 article in the NAIC's Journal of Insurance Regulation calls it not sound: the mileage modifier double-counts miles already in the value, the formula never inspects the car, and critics note the 10% cap comes from no market study. The Diminished Value tool shows what 17c would give, a band of 10% to 20% of the repair cost (the settlement range a claims adjuster reported in that article), your own market figure from two dealer offers, and a claim letter.

Frequently asked questions

What is the 17c formula for diminished value?

A formula from a Georgia class-action settlement with State Farm: 10% of the car's value, times a damage modifier from 0 to 1, times a mileage modifier that reaches 0 at 100,000 miles. A 2023 Journal of Insurance Regulation article calls it not sound, because it double-counts mileage and never inspects the car. Answer a 17c offer with market evidence or an independent appraisal.

Can I claim diminished value from my own insurer?

Rarely. When another driver caused the crash, many states let you claim diminished value from their insurer along with the repair; claiming it from your own insurer is rare, and Georgia is the clear exception after the 2001 State Farm v. Mabry decision.

Is AutoSmith financial, tax or legal advice?

No. AutoSmith is education: arithmetic on the numbers you enter, with every formula shown. Your loan contract, your insurer, your tax preparer and your state motor-vehicle agency are the binding sources.

How AutoSmith works

What is new